The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) confirmed 1,153 complaints against companies in its Homeowners line in 2025, across 9,069,561 policies in force. That line covers homeowners, renters, condo, dwelling and farm policies together. For each company TDI works out a complaint index: the company’s share of confirmed complaints divided by its share of policies. The average is 1.00. A company at 2.00 drew twice as many confirmed complaints as its size would predict; a company at 0.50 drew half as many.

The index is the fairest quick comparison TDI offers, but read it with care. It counts only complaints TDI confirmed, it can jump from one year to the next, and for a small company one or two complaints move it a great deal. We show two years side by side for that reason.

Insurers by brand

Most national brands sell Texas home policies through several legal companies. We add those companies together here; the brand index is our calculation using TDI’s formula on the combined counts.

InsurerPolicies in force, 2025Share of policiesConfirmed complaints, 2025Complaint index, 2025Complaint index, 2024
State Farm1,468,92016.20%2501.34 more than average1.10
Allstate1,097,52212.10%2111.51 more than average1.56
USAA894,4129.86%1080.95 near average0.55
Farmers685,1307.55%460.53 fewer than average1.24
Liberty Mutual431,7434.76%931.69 more than average0.97
Progressive406,9584.49%360.70 fewer than average0.44
Homesite363,0544.00%731.58 more than average1.01
Lemonade353,0843.89%190.42 fewer than average0.56
Travelers326,0793.60%400.96 near average0.79
American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida274,0983.02%90.26 fewer than average1.69
TWIA231,0382.55%120.41 fewer than average0.18
Texas Farm Bureau189,8872.09%100.41 fewer than average0.65
American Modern185,4042.04%50.21 fewer than average0.24
AAA Texas182,1712.01%241.04 near average0.53
Germania146,3471.61%130.70 fewer than average0.36
Texas FAIR Plan127,8351.41%80.49 fewer than average0.00
Ranchers and Farmers Mutual Insurance Company117,6321.30%312.07 more than average1.71
Spinnaker Insurance Company107,4091.18%70.51 fewer than average1.71
Mercury Insurance Company of Texas82,7800.91%121.14 near average—
Nationwide75,6330.83%151.56 more than average2.70
American Security Insurance Company71,5720.79%30.33 fewer than average1.47
Trisura Insurance Company50,7440.56%10.16 fewer than average0.75
Southern Vanguard Insurance Company49,9550.55%00.00 no confirmed complaints1.53
Hochheim Prairie Farm Mutual Insurance Association46,8540.52%00.00 no confirmed complaints0.00
Amica Mutual Insurance Company46,4850.51%30.51 fewer than average0.50
Benchmark Insurance Company43,8330.48%10.18 fewer than average0.77
Toggle Insurance Company41,2480.45%00.00 no confirmed complaints0.00
Occidental Fire & Casualty Company of North Carolina37,0170.41%61.27 more than average2.14
Aventus Insurance Company36,6620.40%20.43 fewer than average0.00
QBE Insurance Corporation35,8560.40%00.00 no confirmed complaints—
Allied Trust Insurance Company35,6410.39%20.44 fewer than average7.50
Underwriters at Lloyd's, London34,6770.38%40.91 near average0.86
Economy Preferred Insurance Company33,9870.37%20.46 fewer than average7.42
R.V.O.S. Farm Mutual Insurance Company32,8680.36%00.00 no confirmed complaints0.36
Capitol County Mutual Fire Insurance Company32,1690.35%20.49 fewer than average0.00
Orion 180 Insurance Company31,4430.35%00.00 no confirmed complaints—
Hartford Insurance Company of the Southeast24,8920.27%41.26 more than average0.60
Palomar Specialty Insurance Company24,1770.27%30.98 near average0.59
Century-National Insurance Company23,9440.26%10.33 fewer than average0.00
Praetorian Insurance Company23,6880.26%216.97 more than average1.68
Triassic Insurance Company23,1070.25%82.72 more than average—
Columbia Lloyds Insurance Company22,7990.25%00.00 no confirmed complaints0.00
Safeport Insurance Company22,6230.25%10.35 fewer than average2.65
Chubb21,4940.24%20.73 fewer than average0.00
Safepoint Insurance Company20,0200.22%10.39 fewer than average0.00

All 145 companies with at least 1,000 policies

Exactly as TDI reports them. Look for the company name printed on your policy or bill, which is often different from the brand on the advertising.

Company (name on the policy)Policies in force, 2025Confirmed complaints, 2025Complaint index, 2025Complaint index, 2024
State Farm Lloyds1,468,9202501.341.10
Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company833,4071711.611.68
ASI Lloyds382,938360.740.46
Lemonade Insurance Company353,084190.420.56
Homesite Insurance Company293,976651.741.21
American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida274,09890.261.70
Travelers Personal Insurance Company273,512371.060.62
United Services Automobile Association272,482240.690.37
USAA Casualty Insurance Company254,542280.870.50
Mid-Century Insurance Company of Texas249,561180.572.15
Texas Windstorm Insurance Association231,038120.410.18
Texas Farmers Insurance Company226,345150.521.05
USAA General Indemnity Company201,508291.130.99
Auto Club Indemnity Company182,171241.040.53
Garrison Property and Casualty Insurance Company165,880271.280.41
Texas Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company152,63370.360.66
Germania Farm Mutual Insurance Association144,509130.710.36
American Economy Insurance Company140,112422.361.09
Safeco Insurance Company of Indiana138,791241.360.25
Texas FAIR Plan Association127,83580.490.00
Allstate Indemnity Company122,547201.281.62
Ranchers and Farmers Mutual Insurance Company117,632312.071.72
American Modern Home Insurance Company107,72910.070.11
Spinnaker Insurance Company107,40970.511.72
Allstate Texas Lloyd's107,313141.030.69
Foremost Lloyds of Texas100,63150.390.38
Mercury Insurance Company of Texas82,780121.14—
American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance Company77,67540.410.42
Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, Michigan73,45900.000.36
American Security Insurance Company71,57230.331.47
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company66,868131.532.18
Homesite Lloyd's of Texas53,35171.030.47
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company52,92400.000.62
Trisura Insurance Company50,74410.160.76
Southern Vanguard Insurance Company49,95500.001.54
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company47,655203.303.01
Hochheim Prairie Farm Mutual Insurance Association46,85400.000.00
Amica Mutual Insurance Company46,48530.510.50
Benchmark Insurance Company43,83310.180.78
Toggle Insurance Company41,24800.000.00
Texas Farm Bureau Underwriters37,25430.630.61
Occidental Fire & Casualty Company of North Carolina37,01761.272.14
Aventus Insurance Company36,66220.430.00
QBE Insurance Corporation35,85600.00—
Allied Trust Insurance Company35,64120.447.52
Underwriters at Lloyd's, London34,67740.910.86
Economy Preferred Insurance Company33,98720.467.44
R.V.O.S. Farm Mutual Insurance Company32,86800.000.36
Capitol County Mutual Fire Insurance Company32,16920.490.00
Orion 180 Insurance Company31,44300.00—
The Travelers Home and Marine Insurance Company29,43520.531.33
Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company28,91751.361.71
Safeco Insurance Company of America28,07600.000.00
Hartford Insurance Company of the Southeast24,89241.260.60
Palomar Specialty Insurance Company24,17730.980.59
Progressive Casualty Insurance Company24,02000.000.00
Century-National Insurance Company23,94410.330.00
Praetorian Insurance Company23,688216.971.69
Triassic Insurance Company23,10782.72—
Columbia Lloyds Insurance Company22,79900.000.00
Safeport Insurance Company22,62310.352.65
Chubb Lloyds Insurance Company of Texas20,83920.750.00
Travelers Lloyds of Texas Insurance Company20,43910.382.17
Liberty Insurance Corporation20,24762.331.25
Safepoint Insurance Company20,02010.390.00
Standard Casualty Company19,58131.211.76
Kin Interinsurance Nexus Exchange19,54600.000.95
The Woodlands Insurance Company19,41210.410.00
Tower Hill Prime Insurance Company19,33210.410.00
Fire Insurance Exchange18,86520.830.95
One Alliance North America Insurance Company17,67610.45—
Homesite Indemnity Company15,72710.500.00
Western Mutual Insurance Company15,44100.000.89
Agricultural Workers Mutual Auto Insurance Company14,36331.641.11
MS Transverse Insurance Company13,86431.700.00
Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company12,51231.892.74
Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange11,99531.971.03
Farmers Lloyds Insurance Company of Texas11,78064.012.57
American Summit Insurance Company11,77810.670.00
Aegis Security Insurance Company11,74300.001.48
Evanston Insurance Company11,72510.670.00
Trisura Specialty Insurance Company11,72310.670.00
Obsidian Insurance Company11,19200.000.00
Encompass Independent Insurance Company11,04474.991.81
National General Insurance Company9,45800.000.00
Horace Mann Insurance Company9,31400.001.40
MIC General Insurance Corporation9,22100.000.00
Incline Casualty Company8,89521.771.24
Great Lakes Reinsurance (U.K.) SE8,09110.970.00
American Hallmark Insurance Company of Texas7,49500.000.00
Insurors Indemnity Company7,38700.000.00
Stillwater Insurance Company7,31633.230.00
U S Lloyds Insurance Company7,15700.000.00
Trumbull Insurance Company6,58600.001.48
The Cincinnati Casualty Company6,34800.000.00
Topa Insurance Company5,66100.000.00
Allstate Insurance Company5,33811.470.00
Nationwide Property and Casualty Insurance Company5,33411.471.88
Mdow Insurance Company4,89600.000.00
Farmers Mutual Insurance Association of Burnet County4,71811.670.00
Scottsdale Insurance Company4,68111.682.40
Twin City Fire Insurance Company4,67300.000.00
Acceptance Indemnity Insurance Company4,67158.420.00
Garfield Farm Mutual Insurance Association4,61700.000.00
Farmers Insurance Exchange4,48900.002.44
Austin County Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Association, Incorporated4,39500.000.00
Esurance Insurance Company4,37235.40—
Property and Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford4,28111.842.38
Convex Insurance Uk Limited4,22100.000.00
Aig Property Casualty Company4,18611.880.00
National Fire & Marine Insurance Company4,10000.000.00
Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company3,95235.970.00
Berkley Insurance Company3,87100.000.00
Texas Pioneer Farm Mutual Insurance Association, Inc.3,46000.000.00
Nationwide Insurance Company of America3,43012.292.93
Muenster Farm Mutual Fire Insurance Association, Inc.3,41300.000.00
Acuity, A Mutual Insurance Company3,37012.330.00
German-American Farm Mutual2,95400.004.22
Engle Farmers Mutual Benefit Association2,95300.000.00
The Cincinnati Insurance Company2,78900.000.00
Centauri Specialty Insurance Company2,75412.860.00
Canopius US Insurance, Inc.2,66900.00—
Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Association of Comal County2,50000.000.00
Lancashire Insurance Company (Uk) Limited2,42200.000.00
American National Lloyds Insurance Company2,41826.510.00
Travelers Commercial Insurance Company2,27800.004.39
Independent Mutual Fire Insurance Company2,04600.000.00
Farmers Mutual Insurance of Washington County2,01100.000.00
Bankers Standard Insurance Company1,93600.000.00
Armed Forces Insurance Exchange1,93600.000.00
Integon National Insurance Company1,92528.171.21
Liberty Lloyds of Texas Insurance Company1,87900.005.10
Germania Property & Casualty Insurance Company1,83800.000.00
Teachers Insurance Company1,79000.000.00
Zurich American Insurance Company1,69800.000.00
Gillespie Farm Mutual Insurance Company1,56700.000.00
Midvale Indemnity Company1,51400.000.00
Axa Xl Insurance Company Uk Ltd1,37000.000.00
Central Insurance Company1,36600.00—
Safeco Lloyds Insurance Company1,35800.000.00
Hartford Lloyd's Insurance Company1,19300.000.00
Mount Vernon Fire Insurance Company1,08100.000.00
Nusureco Insurance Company1,04300.000.00
State National Insurance Company, Inc.1,03800.000.00
Arch Insurance Company1,02700.000.00

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, Complaint indexes and policy counts for insurance companies. Data and methods.

How to use this page

  • Compare like with like. A complaint index only means something next to other insurers’. The full list shows every company.
  • Complaints are not claims. TDI counts complaints it confirmed, about any part of the service: claims, billing, cancellations. A low index does not promise a smooth claim.
  • Check financial strength separately. We do not publish financial ratings because the rating agencies own them and change them. Ask the agent or look up the company at a rating agency such as AM Best.
  • Nothing here is a recommendation. We do not rank insurers as good or bad, and we are not paid by any of them.

Related guides