At the end of 2025, the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) counted 185,404 residential property policies in force with the 2 American Modern companies listed below. That is 2.04% of all policies in TDI’s Homeowners line, which includes renters, condo and dwelling policies as well as homeowners policies, and ranks American Modern number 13 among the insurers we track.

TDI confirmed 5 complaints against them in 2025. That gives a complaint index of 0.21, below the average of 1.00. That means fewer confirmed complaints than the share of policies would predict. With so few complaints, one or two more would move the index a lot. Treat it as a rough signal. TDI publishes an index for each legal company. The combined figure is our calculation, applying TDI’s formula to the companies’ added-up complaints and policies.

In 2024 the index was 0.24, on 4 confirmed complaints and 203,481 policies. The two years tell a consistent story.

0.21
Complaint index, 2025
5
Confirmed complaints, 2025
185,404
Policies in force, 2025
2.04%
Share of policies

The companies behind the American Modern name

Complaints and rate filings are recorded against the legal company that issued the policy. Check the company name on your declarations page to see which row is yours.

Company (name on the policy)NAICPolicies in force, 2025Confirmed complaints, 2025Complaint index, 2025Policies in force, 2024Confirmed complaints, 2024Complaint index, 2024
American Modern Home Insurance Company23469107,72910.07115,15910.11
American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance Company4272277,67540.4188,32230.42

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, Complaint indexes and policy counts for insurance companies. Data and methods.

American Modern rate filings in Texas

Texas insurers must file their home insurance rates with TDI before using them, and TDI reviews the filings for compliance with state law. TDI’s records show 15 homeowners or dwelling rate filings from American Modern companies received since 2021. The largest overall increase among them was +24.0%, in a filing received September 29, 2022 for Dwelling Program.

The percentage is the insurer’s estimate of the overall effect on its existing policyholders. Your own change can be higher or lower. A blank or 0% means the filing changed rules or something else that does not move premiums overall.

Received by TDICompany (name on the policy)ProductOverall rate changeEffective, new policiesEffective, renewalsStatusSERFF ID
2026-05-20American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyHomeowners Flex Program0.0%——PendingAMMH-134949198
2024-10-30American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyHomeowners Flex+6.8%2026-03-112026-05-04ReviewedAMMH-134286881
2024-06-11American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyHomeowners Flex+21.6%2024-08-202024-10-21ReviewedAMMH-134128083
2024-04-22American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyHomeowners Flex+21.3%2024-09-112024-11-04WithdrawnAMMH-134061708
2024-04-04American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyDwelling Program+19.6%2024-07-172024-09-09WithdrawnAMMH-134038506
2024-02-05American Modern Home Insurance CompanyRenters Program+10.0%2024-12-092024-10-21ReviewedAMMH-133962217
2024-02-05American Modern Home Insurance CompanyRenters Program0.0%2024-12-092024-10-21ReviewedAMMH-133961522
2023-08-31American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyCondominium Program+11.8%2023-11-082023-11-18ReviewedAMMH-133797577
2023-08-04American Modern Home Insurance CompanyRenters Program0.0%2024-01-102024-02-03ReviewedAMMH-133764913
2023-06-15American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyHomeowners Flex+9.1%2023-11-082023-11-18ReviewedAMMH-133706579
2023-02-15American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyDwelling Program-13.1%2023-07-122023-08-05ReviewedAMMH-133520649
2022-09-29American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyDwelling Program+24.0%2022-12-072022-12-17ReviewedAMMH-133397081
2022-09-19American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyCondominium Program+18.0%2022-11-222022-12-02ReviewedAMMH-133399092
2022-01-07American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyManufactured Home Program+6.4%2022-04-062022-04-16ReviewedAMMH-133101351
2021-12-21American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance CompanyHomeowners FLEX+3.6%2022-08-102022-09-08ReviewedAMMH-133088166

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, Home and auto rate filings. Search every filing, with documents, in TDI’s rate filing data.

How to use this page

  • Compare like with like. A complaint index only means something next to other insurers’. The full list shows every company.
  • Complaints are not claims. TDI counts complaints it confirmed, about any part of the service: claims, billing, cancellations. A low index does not promise a smooth claim.
  • Check financial strength separately. We do not publish financial ratings because the rating agencies own them and change them. Ask the agent or look up the company at a rating agency such as AM Best.
  • Nothing here is a recommendation. We do not rank insurers as good or bad, and we are not paid by any of them.

Related guides

Other insurers